Please leave a comment, particularly if you have your own “Why can’t they just…” question, or email us at whycanttheyjust@gmail.com. We’d love to hear from you.
Find out more about us and how you can support us at https://whycanttheyjust.com.au/, which includes a link to our Patreon site where you can sign up for exclusive content.
Please also feel free to rate and review us, as it does help people to find us.
Music: “Insurrection”
Written by Pierre Chrétien
Performed by the Soul Jazz Orchestra
Courtesy of Do Right Music Inc.
18 November 2026
Luke
Welcome to another episode of Why Can’t They Just, discussing politics, policy and getting stuff done. I’m Luke Robertson, a conservation biology and environmental policy student.
Janaline
I’m Janaline Oh. I’m a former diplomat and a climate, environment and anti-racism activist.
Yassine
And I’m Yassine Andrews, and I’m a year 11 student.
Janaline
Before we start, I’d like to acknowledge that we are all recording this on the unceded lands of First Nations people in Australia. Recognising that sovereignty was never ceded, we pay our respects to their elders past and present, and we extend those respects to any First Nations listeners that we have today.
So today we’re going to do something a little bit different again. We’re talking about the economic implications of women’s economic empowerment, both at a personal level and also at an economy-wide level. Glenn’s not with us today, so I’m talking with Luke and Yassine. Because I’m also really keen to hear their views on this very important question, which is very relevant to both of their futures.
So one of the things that the Albanese Labor government has been tremendously proud of is narrowing the gender pay gap. Before we start, I think we should just be clear about what the gender pay gap is and isn’t. So the gender pay gap is not women being paid less than men for the same job. That has been illegal in Australia for many decades.
The gender pay gap in a sector is the total amount of money that is earned by the women in that sector divided by the number of women and the total amount of money earned by men in that sector divided by the number of men. So it gives the average amount of money earned by men and the average amount of money earned by women in that sector.
In a sector with a big gender pay gap, what that tends to mean is that women are in lower paying jobs in that sector. So for example, childcare has one of the biggest gender pay gaps. And the reason for that is that most of the educators who are paid less are women, and most of the bosses of the companies that run for-profit childcare are men. Obviously a corporate boss is going to earn a lot more than a childcare educator.
What the government is celebrating when they’re celebrating a narrowing of the gender pay gap is, under their policies, they are claiming, women are now in relatively better paying jobs than they were before.
So across the economy, the gender pay gap also reflects things like mining and construction, which are very, very well paid sectors where most of the jobs are held by men - they’re very male-dominated - whereas the care sectors, which are less well paid, are very heavily dominated by women.
So I said childcare is a sector where there is a big gender pay gap within the sector, but within the economy, childcare is relatively less well paid than mining, which is why being an underwater welder is actually not a bad career choice.
In addition to this, a lot of unpaid work and domestic labour is carried out by women, which means that women are more likely to hold part-time jobs or casual jobs and therefore work fewer hours. And obviously if you work fewer hours, you are going to be earning less.
So what do you guys think about this situation and what, if anything, do you think should be done to change it?
Luke
Organise. Childcare got huge pay rises in the past couple of years and I think they were locked in for the next three years this year, if I recall correctly. But that was done through the United Workers Union. They had some pretty intense lobbying efforts through their Big Steps campaign, and obviously made a contribution to close the gender pay gap because in a very female-dominated sector, they were able to push the rate of wages up for educators. So yeah, that’s my advice, I guess.
But it’s an interesting point. I wonder what it will look like in 10 years on its continued path. I’m noticing a lot more women in STEM. That’s a trend that I’ve seen. I wonder if that will make a contribution.
There was some interview where I saw Tanya Plibersek say gender equality is not a zero-sum game and we don’t need to push one sex down to pull another one up. The inclusion of things that can help everyone, things like fee-free TAFE and all those sorts of things can help encourage women to get into sectors where they might previously not feel empowered to do so, is a great thing.
I don’t claim to have the answers to this, but I would organize. Like in New South Wales, I think cops get heaps more money than nurses. That doesn’t sound completely fair to me.
Janaline
Yeah, I think definitely this Labor government, and Tanya Plibersek is of course now the Minister for Social Services and has been a campaigner for narrowing the gender pay gap since she entered Parliament. So there’s a significant number of female politicians who’ve been working for many years on this issue.
And I think one of the measures that they have really grasped since they came back into government in 2022 is raising the value and the remuneration of care workers - so aged care workers, childcare workers and healthcare workers - and that has, as you say, Luke, made a dent at least in the gender pay gap.
Because it’s true. I mean, people on mining sites - your cousin Yassine, who works as a fly-in fly-out mine worker, wielding a sledgehammer on the end of an abseiling rope, makes a very, very, very high salary, much, much higher than your sister when she spent two years working as a childcare educator.
What is the relative social value of those two tasks? What is the relative contribution to the economy and to the society of those two tasks? I think that’s a really interesting question.
I would say, though, that quite clearly the economy rewards the sledgehammer job much, much more highly than it does the childcare job.
Yassine
I feel like it’s quite subjective which one is more important though. So like how do you decide that?
Janaline
Well, I think it’s an interesting question though, because clearly the economy’s decided that Tom’s job in the mine is more important than Zari’s job in child care.
So I think that’s actually a really interesting point, Luke. I think organising is really important because one of the reasons that mine workers who used to be paid nothing, I mean, it was famous in the 19th century that people would go down to the coal mines and be paid literally a pittance. The reason that they got such good wages is because they organised. So yes, I think the United Workers Union should definitely be very proud of its achievements.
But I think also having a government that is majority female that also has explicit policy goals around narrowing the gender pay gap and promoting women’s economic empowerment is also pretty important, because a lot of these things are policy issues. And one of the things about the care sector is that unlike the mining sector, it is a sector that is very, very largely publicly funded.
So there is a bit of a tension there, where people don’t want to be paying massive taxes to boost the wages of childcare workers. But on the other hand, the childcare workers and the nurses and the aged care workers are delivering really, really essential services that people do very much value.
Yassine.
Yassine
Okay, you said that women have to do more unpaid labour, like caring roles. But I guess women have to do some of that, at least, because they have to take time off for themselves when they have a baby, but also breastfeed them and stuff. So biologically, have to care more.
Janaline
Yes. It is an important point, right? I mean, what about parental leave? I think one of the things that has been found internationally is that countries that offer equal parental leave to both parents and, even more than that, countries that create policy incentives for both parents to take roughly equal amounts of time off in parental leave tend to have much, much better outcomes on gender pay equality. And the reason for that is because both parents then have roughly the same amount of time out of the workforce and have similar career progression outcomes.
An interesting study about 20 years ago found that women who have children tend to see their incomes flatline or decrease over the next 10 years. Men who had children tended to see their incomes increase over the next 10 years. It seems that having babies made men more promotable and made women less promotable. And I guess it’s not surprising if the woman is the one who takes the time off to care for the child, who perhaps then goes back part time, who perhaps doesn’t apply for promotion or takes herself out of the promotion stream in order to have more time to undertake her caring responsibilities.
So I think the structural things that you probably need to change in that context are things like making everybody take equal amounts of parental leave and more importantly, making sure that the bosses of those people treat them equally. In other words, not stigmatizing men who apply for parental leave.
Did you want to say something else?
Yassine
Well, I was going to say like the attitude has to change to reduce stigma on parental leave. It has to be kind of accepted as a universal thing that has to be done, rather than like not being committed to your job or whatever.
Janaline
Yeah, I think it goes beyond that as well because, of course, you don’t just have a baby for six months or a year. They stick around for a while.
Yassine
There’s a problem with that?
Janaline
What I’m saying is: babies hang around not just for a year; babies hang around for the next 20 years. So it’s not just about parental leave when they’re babies. It’s also about flexibility when they’re toddlers and in preschool and in primary school and you need to pick them up from daycare by six o’clock in the evening because that’s when the daycares close. So it’s also about workplaces changing their culture and being more sympathetic to the idea that you might suddenly have to take a day off because your kid is sick. And it shouldn’t just be the mother who does that.
So gender pay inequality is often framed as a women’s issue or a social justice issue, but it’s pretty clear it’s also a productivity issue with some pretty significant macroeconomic implications. According to KPMG and the Workplace Gender Equality Agency, persistent pay disparities cost the Australian economy an estimated $1.26 billion every week in lost earnings in the last year. That is not just money left off household balance sheets: it affects consumer spending; it suppresses productivity; and it’s a massive underutilisation of skilled labour.
Failing to fully utilise female talent and underpaying female dominated sectors limits national productivity, reduces total household spending and strains Australia’s retirement income system. This income gap compounds exponentially over a working lifespan. Lower base pay combined with career breaks for unpaid care translates into quite a significant retirement gap. Australian women retire with significantly less superannuation than men on average, creating a systemic long-term dependency on the pension and shifting quite significant fiscal pressure onto future taxpayers.
So, what do we think about this? And is women’s economic empowerment just about not having as much pay or is it also about power?
Yassine
It’s definitely about power. Women make up 42% of sole trader businesses but only 15% of owner-led incorporated companies, and women are about a third of business owners in Australia. In corporate jobs, I think that women, to get respect or promotions, they have to kind of act like a man, like constantly be available. So women who have babies are seen as not being as committed to their jobs. If you have a baby, you’re not very manly, obviously. So you’re looked down upon, which is why I guess people don’t really ask for parental leave, especially fathers, because there’s this like stigma behind it, but I guess that’s gotten better.
But it does make sense that women would want to start their own business more because when they’re the boss they can do what they want to do and it kind of eliminates that stigma.
Janaline
So do you think that’s about power or flexibility or both?
Yassine
Both.
Janaline
Yeah, it’s interesting because the Commonwealth Bank recently released some research that showed burnout and mental load was a very, very significant challenge cited by women founders and business owners. And mental load, of course, is where even if you’re not the one who is picking up the children and organizing dinner, you’re the one who needs to remember who’s got swimming lessons at what time and organise someone to make sure that the kid gets there. Even at corporate boss level, there seems to be an understanding that it’s the woman who is responsible for making sure that kids get picked up from school and go to their medical appointments and go to their sporting fixtures.
I think potentially being a sole trader means, even though you can employ people, you’re the boss and you get to decide, you get to have that flexibility for yourself and that’s not imposed by other people.
Luke, what do you think about this?
Luke
What do you, what do you guys mean by like power to have power over the women to make them lose their jobs or to have power to…? I’m a bit confused.
Janaline
I think it’s about women having the power to determine their own work hours and their own work conditions. So if you’re the boss, if you’re a sole trader and you’ve set up your own business, then you’re the one who gets to decide what hours you work. You don’t rely on anybody else for a promotion because you’re the boss. So I think…
Luke
That’s a good point. I think that’s that’s probably a big part of the reason, hey?
Janaline
Yeah, I think so.
Luke
I mean, getting kids to and from school and to and from sport, whatever they’re doing. Yeah, it can be quite inflexible, quite rigid, a nine to five schedule and not having flexibility to do what you need.
But again, I would say organize. Because things like the public service have much more flexibility than a lot of corporate jobs. That didn’t happen by accident.
But that, I’ll be honest, that surprised me. I didn’t realize that there were more female sole traders than there were women who were in corporate jobs.
Janaline
Sorry, that’s not -
Luke
Are they more likely to be?
Janaline
It’s that women make up about a third of business owners, but they’re 42% of sole traders and they’re only 15% of owners of incorporated companies. So what that means is, if you’re an incorporated company, you have a much bigger scope for expansion. Like it’s much easier to get finance. It’s just much easier to expand your business.
So the way in which our corporate affairs are structured, sole traders tend to be quite small. They will be a single person who might employ a few people, but you don’t have sole traders employing hundreds of people. You really need to have a company structure in order to do that. A sole trader business is a very small business.
Luke
But if you were the business owner and you incorporated your business, could you not set your own terms?
Janaline
I think the issue is, yes, you probably can set your own terms, but it’s an incredible time commitment to incorporate a business and to run an incorporated business.
Yassine
But if you run an incorporated business, can you even take time off if you run it? Because you have so many things to do.
Janaline
Well, this is a bit of a founder’s dilemma, right? I mean, famously, the founders of all those tech companies, the first two years, they basically sleep in the office and do nothing but work. So maybe that is also the issue.
Yassine
That’s also probably why women don’t do that. I mean, I guess that’s the same point.
Janaline
I mean, in terms of the productivity loss, I think one of the real challenges for modern economies, and particularly in developed countries like Australia, where the care sector and the services sector are so important, is actually what we call productivity and how we measure it.
Because economic measures of productivity in the past have always been about making stuff. They’ve been very much focused on concrete outputs. So it’s easy to measure the productivity of a widget factory because you look at how much money and energy and labour goes into producing a widget. And if you can produce more widgets with the same amount of input, then that’s a productivity increase.
If your widgets are not actual things that you can touch and hold, but your widgets are healthcare outcomes or care of the elderly or the education of children, then it’s actually much harder to measure that productivity.
And even in other services like hairdressing, for example, is a hairdresser more productive if they can cut more people’s hair in an hour, but the haircuts are terrible compared to cutting fewer people’s hair in an hour, but the haircuts are fantastic?
One of the ways in which you can measure the productivity of a hairdresser, for example, is how much they can actually charge people. Because obviously, if you’re producing three haircuts in an hour, 20 minutes each, and they’re pretty terrible, people aren’t going to pay very much money for that. But if you only cut one head in an hour and it’s really fantastic, that person might be willing to pay quite a lot.
Yassine
But also, if you do terrible haircuts, then those people won’t come back, so you’ll lose money as well.
Janaline
That’s true. You’ll probably go out of business unless your customers are me.
Luke
If you charge higher for a single haircut, that would have - still be productive? Because it’s a lot of capital going into it?
Janaline
Well, I think that’s the point. For something as concrete as a haircut, maybe you can measure that by how much you can charge people. So it’s basically for the amount of effort that you’re putting into it, you’re getting more money so that looks more productive.
It’s much harder when you’re talking about, let’s say, childcare. Let’s say you’re looking after four kids. How do you measure the quality of the care you’re giving those kids? Because the quality of the care you’re giving those kids is going to manifest in ways across that child’s life that are not easily measured at the end of the year. So yes, you can measure if they’ve met their developmental benchmarks, or if they’re happy.
But that’s not how it’s measured. The Australian Bureau of Statistics doesn’t go around childcare centres and look at how happy the kids are and how many kids are toilet trained by age three.
I think there is a real challenge in how you measure productivity. I mean, how do you measure productivity in the disability care sector? Is it about the number of people that you see or is it about the quality of the life of the people that you’re servicing?
I don’t know really what the answer is, but I think all of these measures that show Australian productivity is declining I think are misleading because in some ways it’s actually the measurement that’s the problem.
I mean this also comes to a really big tension and probably the reason that mining workers get paid more than childcare workers. In the private sector, you can measure productivity by how much people are willing to pay for a service. In the public sector, it’s much, much harder to do that because it’s taxpayers’ money. People don’t have a choice as to whether they pay taxes or not.
They do have a choice about government spending in the sense that they can vote people in or out depending on how they feel about their economic management. But three-year elections are a very blunt instrument.
I think there is a really big debate to be had in this country about the value of those services and how we measure that value, and what we are willing as a society to pay for those outcomes. Because I really feel at the moment that people expect a lot of quality, and people complain a lot about a lack of quality, but they’re not necessarily willing to pay for it.
Luke
There’s a lot of good points in there. On the public sector point, yeah, I wonder how productivity is measured there because the output of a given Act may not be productive at all. In fact, things like an environmental impact assessment would be antithetical to the idea of productivity, but that’s not why we do them. It’s because it’s the right thing to do.
Coming back to the gender pay gap, I wonder how it would change if we took a more holistic approach to productivity, things like child care of course, and a lot of female-dominated public services like midwifery, nursing, social work. And I don’t know what it would look like, how you would even begin to measure that. That’s a big question.
Janaline
Yeah, definitely how to measure the productivity of services has always been a big issue. And the usual measure is how much people are willing to pay for that service. But as we’ve just discussed, it’s really hard to gauge how much people are willing to pay for public services. It’s very difficult in a system that is biased very heavily on quantitative measurement.
Yassine?
Yassine
I feel like productivity is definitely more quality over quantity because it’s not better to have a million services but not get any quality.
Janaline
So maybe we should have more philosophy and less statistics in economic measurement.
Yassine
I agree with this.
I think to be able to tackle the gender pay gap and power and wealth disparities between the genders, you have to change society’s perception of women and how they view an ideal worker.
Janaline
So one of the things that former sex discrimination commissioner Elizabeth Broderick used to say, about 10 years ago when she was in that position, was that dealing with gender equality in the workplace actually didn’t just require measures to help women have more flexibility or be able to take time off or have equal access to promotions. It was also necessary to look at the way in which workplaces are structured and the way in which workplace culture rewards certain things and disincentivizes other things and in particular, she identified this concept of what she called the ideal worker.
Now the ideal worker is someone who shows up all the time, who can work late, disappear at short notice to go on a work trip. None of those things are really possible if you have significant caring responsibilities. And that’s not only children, that can also be for elderly people, it can be for someone with a disability.
One of the things that she was advocating was that workplaces look at the structure of how they conducted their work and whether it was possible to produce the outcomes that they were looking for in a different way that didn’t feed into this idea of the ideal worker.
Luke
Yeah, I mean I’ve had a few jobs in my life and the ones I had before my current job, there was a lot of that last minute show up for these jobs that were often quite late and through the night into the morning hours.
Janaline
What job was that?
Luke
I did rigging, setting up lights and sound for events. I was subcontracted for a period of time; I didn’t get super. It was pretty unsafe at times, I’d say. I almost had my kneecap crushed once, which was pretty bad. The point I’m trying to get to is: the ideal worker is from the eyes of certain business owners, it does not conform to the life of those who are doing the work. Being able to come in last minute, cop all sorts of crap in the workplace. I certainly think it’s something that culturally needs to change because it is not acceptable for people to be working all those extra hours and not get paid for it.
In Australia, the average full-time worker works an average of 4 1/2 weeks in unpaid overtime, which is just obscene.
Janaline
It is actually illegal.
Luke
I know, right?
Janaline
That is literally wage theft.
Luke
Yeah, exactly. It’s something that gives me the irrits because that’s not fair. You shouldn’t have to cop staying back more than you have to, not getting paid for it, just so life’s a little bit easier for your boss.
Janaline
What do you think, Yassine?
Yassine
Yeah, I definitely think the ideal worker is like not human. You just have to have no life. But I think that the idea of the ideal worker being like, I guess, more conforming to what men are able to do, kind of aligns with Simone de Beauvoir’s idea that men are the default and women have to try to align with their standards.
Janaline
So when did Simone de Beauvoir write this?
Yassine
1949.
Janaline
So 77 years ago, and we’re still talking about it, because it’s actually a thing now.
We’re going to talk about gender issues in a more social sense to do with things like women’s health in a coming episode. But it is actually a real thing where in a lot of our economic structures, men are the default. And there is a kind of default assumption of what a person is and it’s a male person.
Yassine
So de Beauvoir also said this idea that man is the human and women are females, which is just like an accessory to a male.
Janaline
Or a modified version.
Yassine
Or a modified version of a male.
Janaline
So this sort of goes back to Genesis when Eve was fashioned from Adam’s rib. So maybe it’s been with us for a long time.
Yassine
I think it has.
Janaline
So how do we actually stop workplaces from demanding that people do this? How do things change?
Luke
At the time I was working at my previous job, a lot of that stuff was legal. And then they closed a lot of those loopholes with the, I think it was called the closing loopholes bill. Which got rid of things like forcing people to be contractors: that’s illegal. But Sally McManus, when she was still head of the ACTU, said that there’s a difference between having rights at work and having them enforced.
So there’s a real disconnect there because there were things that happened there that I would have called out if I wasn’t A, naive to the fact that it was a problem, and B, had the confidence to do so.
Janaline
It’s pretty rough if enforcement has to rely on teenage casual workers calling out bad behaviour. That seems to be an insufficient enforcement framework to me.
Luke
Yeah, it is.
Janaline
So do we think we need more workplace inspections or do we need more…? What’s the policy solution to that?
Luke
Yeah, I don’t know, maybe inspections, because a lot of the time, things like working at heights without a licence, rigging without a licence, all that sort of thing, it was pretty bad.
Yassine
It sounds so bad.
Janaline
It sounds so bad.
Yassine
This ideal worker is expecting more than you agreed to. Like you agreed to work these hours, but if you have to drop everything and go somewhere, I feel like that’s not part of it, right? What happens if you just don’t want to do it?
Janaline
So I think this comes to Luke’s point about organising. I mean, it does come fundamentally to an imbalance of power. And this isn’t just a gender thing. I mean, this is a worker thing. It’s about an imbalance of power between workers and bosses, because workers rely on having those jobs. And if they speak out too much, there is always the fear that they can be sacked.
Which is the reason that people started organising into labour unions in the first place. Because bosses can sack a single worker, they can’t sack their entire workforce. So it was about recognising that an individual doesn’t have much power, but all of the workers collectively have quite a lot of power.
But it somewhat shocks me that in the 21st century, this is still a thing. So I think it’s got to be about more inspections. It’s got to be about more rigorous government enforcement of the rules, because clearly bosses aren’t doing it by themselves. So I think steadily improving those conditions is important.
But then you will get the Liberal Party and the Business Council of Australia saying that this is a massive drag on Australian productivity and that one of the reasons that Australian productivity is so bad is because we have all of these productivity-sapping industrial relations requirements.
Yassine
What does that mean?
Janaline
Businesses can’t make as much profit if they can’t exploit their workers in this way.
Yassine
But is productivity more important than workers’ wellness?
Luke
No.
Janaline
Well, I guess the argument - I think the argument of the business owners would be that, across the economy, if you want to be creating wealth - and creating wealth does benefit everybody - if you want to be in a position where wages can increase without boosting inflation, then you need to have high productivity.
Which comes back to my issue that I think the way in which we measure productivity is potentially problematic. And I think we do need to have a big debate in our society as well around how we measure these things, because how you measure things actually significantly affects how you deliver them and what the incentives are.
And I think what Elizabeth Broderick was proposing as sex discrimination commissioner when she said we need to actually have a change in the culture about how the workplace is structured so that there isn’t this reliance on the ideal worker to deliver the outcomes is actually really important. And I don’t know what that looks like and it probably looks like different things in different workplaces.
A number of studies have found that businesses that have given their workers a four-day week, paying them the same, and requiring the same output from them, have actually found it to be incredibly successful. So maybe there are ways of improving productivity without compromising worker wellbeing.
That’s been a pretty interesting discussion. Luke, did you have any final thoughts you’d like to share with us?
Luke
Yeah, obviously I’m not a woman, so I’m not best placed to talk about the gender pay gap. Let’s not have men decide how to solve the gender pay gap. No, absolutely, it’s very important for men to think about these things, particularly young men. I know a lot of young men who have said things like they wouldn’t hire women because of maternity leave. That’s pretty horrible.
Janaline
That is pretty breathtaking, actually.
Luke
Yeah, I know.
Janaline
Because up until the passage of equal employment legislation in the early 1970s, the Australian public service would sack women when they got married on the understanding that once you got married, you were going to have children and not be committed to your job and take time off. So I’m a bit horrified that you know young men who are saying this.
Yassine
But I feel like young men are like going backwards in time.
Luke
Yeah, I think the most salient point from this whole thing is the point you raised, Janaline, about the ideal worker and how that is seen as a baseline for a productive economy, when the ideal worker is a worker who gives up their rights and allows their boss to exploit them illegally. I think it’s time that the business community, they obviously won’t, but, accept that the ideal worker is A, illegal and B, should not be the norm.
Janaline
Well said, Luke. Yassine?
Yassine
I think it’s insane that there’s so much stigma around like women and like maternity leave because you’re literally creating life. Women are the backbone of humanity. We are holding up humanity. No one would exist. Like, let’s just consider that: you’re literally in one human body in like a few months, less than a year, you’re creating a whole person. Like come on. Anyway, I feel very strongly about that.
Please appreciate these women guys. They are so cool.
Janaline
Well said. Look, I think there’s a lot more to women’s economic empowerment than just the gender pay gap, although I think it is important and I think it is really, really important that we have a government now that is very, very focused on recognising the value of female-dominated care work in particular. And the importance of having that work remunerated and recognised in the way that equally important work in more male-dominated sectors is remunerated and recognised.
I do think though that it raises some really important social questions about what the society is willing to pay for because I come back to the fact that a lot of that female-dominated care work is in fact funded by the government, whereas most of the male-dominated construction, mining, that kind of work is very much in the private sector and therefore I can see the arguments of the people who say, ‘oh, well, that’s productive work because it’s generating income, whereas this work is not generating income and therefore it’s not worth it’.
But I think it really comes down to how we value human wellbeing and human quality of life. Frankly, the people who say, ‘oh, but it’s not productive because it’s not earning income’ are going to take a very different view when they are old and they need care. or they have parents who are old and need care, or they have children who need childcare.
So I think we need to find a model for measuring productivity that is not just based on crude measures of what markets are able to deliver and what people are willing to pay in a market context.
I’m not saying smash capitalism, but I am saying that I think in developed countries where care work and services are relatively so much more important in terms of their share of the economy and in terms of their impact on actual people’s lives, I think we do need to have a proper debate within our society about how we value that work and how it is reflected in people’s pay packets and conditions.
And just as a final point, I think a really, really important mechanism for dealing with women’s economic empowerment and gender pay equality is to not just look at the actual pay packets, but to go back and look at the structures and the incentives within the workplace that are leading to exploitation, that are leading to devaluing of certain types of roles and that are trying to produce things in a way that relies on, you know, this ideal worker concept.
So I think all of these things are really big, difficult questions that I don’t have any easy answers to, but I really think we don’t have enough debate about how we’re actually structuring our economy and how we’re actually valuing the contribution of all our workers, not just the women.
Luke
Well, that wraps up another episode of Why Can’t They Just. Our theme music for this program is a piece called Insurrection by Pierre Chrétien, performed by the Soul Jazz Orchestra, courtesy of Do Right Music Inc.
Janaline
You can also hear us on Canberra community radio 2XX FM 98.3 on Tuesdays between 6 and 7 or via 2xxfm.org.au.
If you like our work, consider supporting us on Patreon via our website, whycanttheyjust.com.au.
Luke
I’m Luke Robertson.
Yassine
I’m Yassine Andrews.
Janaline
I’m Janaline Oh, and this is Why Can’t They Just.

Janaline is a former diplomat and current climate, environment and anti-racism activist.
“As a longstanding Canberra-based bureaucrat, I believe in the power of policy to shape and improve lives. I am also acutely aware of the importance of having those policies understood by the people affected by them.
“I started Why Can’t They Just? as way of moving beyond slogans and into what policies really are and what they mean for real people.”

Luke is a student in conservation biology and environmental policy.
“I got interested in public policy and particularly environmental policy around 2020, seeing the damage that things like the ‘Wild Horse Heritage Bill’ did to Kosciuszko National Park, as well as budget cuts made to the national parks service that eventually worsened the Black Summer Bushfires.
“I joined the Policy for People and Why Can’t they Just team after seeing the hard fought passage of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act and the power of community organising for good. I am now hoping to help with community outreach in all areas of policy to make Australia the fairest and most equitable country that it can be.”

Yassine is in Year 11 at a public school.
“I think it is important for the younger generation to be interested in and aware of policy and its impacts on their current and future lives - especially since a lot of young people have no interest in government policies.
I joined Why Can’t They Just and Policy 4 People because I think that it is important to have the perspective of a younger Gen Z. I think people my age need to be a part of the discussion and taken into consideration when talking about the impacts of policy. Since I have lots of strong opinions about things, I can express them in the context of policy through the podcast.”